Scarecrows (Mentawai Islands)

Scarecrows is an exposed left-hand reef break in the Mentawai Islands, set on a reef with sharp coral and rocks. Multiple sources describe it as reliably surfable, with long, peeling walls and good-to-excellent wave quality—especially during the core season when swell and wind line up well. For timing, high tide is emphasized as the safer and best period to surf, because the inside reef becomes very shallow at low tide. Some guidance also notes it can be worked on all tides, but the overall recommendation remains to prioritize high water and to be mindful of falling tide conditions. Wind-wise, the spot benefits when winds come from around the East to Northeast (described as offshore), which helps groom the wave face for cleaner rides. Wind reliability is described as moderate, with a reported split between clean and blown conditions; the most favorable months overlap with the dry-season pattern (notably April through October, with a particular best around April in one guide). Safety is a key consideration: the break is reef-based and exposed, and hazards include rocks/coral and strong sweeping currents during larger southern swells. Rescue and medical support are limited on the islands, so plan with local support/charter logistics, and consider bringing reef-protective gear and appropriate foot protection.